Wavves releases ‘Cherry Soda’ as a solo album after removing Max Bemis and re-recording it in days. Inside the troubled rollout
When Wavves releases ‘Cherry Soda‘ on November 13, it will arrive as something its creator never originally intended: a solo record, built from the wreckage of a collaboration that collapsed in real time. The album, out on I Surrender Records and Bose Records, began life as a joint project between Nathan Williams and Say Anything’s Max Bemis. By the time it reaches listeners, Bemis has been scrubbed from it entirely, and the story of how that happened has become inseparable from the music itself.
The unraveling was swift. The record was announced in July with the single ‘Deathx1k,’ followed by ‘Still Alive’ in August, and positioned as an unlikely meeting of two scene veterans. Then, roughly two weeks before its planned September 18 release, the rollout stopped. A 17-year-old had accused Bemis of carrying on a months-long inappropriate relationship conducted through social media, texts, and phone calls. The allegations, which have not been adjudicated, were enough for Williams to pull the project apart.
Starting Over on a Deadline
What Williams did next is the kind of decision that defines a career. Rather than shelve nearly a year of work, he went back into the studio to excise Bemis and rebuild the album as a straight Wavves release. The math was brutal. By his own account, he “effectively had 12 days to write and record 6 songs” to replace what had to go, a sprint that would rattle most artists but fits the ragged, impulsive spirit Wavves has traded on since the beginning.
Williams has not been diplomatic about his former collaborator. He has said he barely knew Bemis, called his studio presence “awful,” and offered a line that doubles as a thesis for the whole ordeal. “The real thing that hurts is he spent 3 days in the studio and I spent 11 months,” he said, framing the fallout less as a betrayal than as an insult to the labor he had poured into the record. It is a strikingly unsentimental way to describe a professional rupture, and it tells you how little Williams intends to let the episode define him.
The result is a twelve-track album that carries the fingerprints of its own crisis. New singles ‘Pinesol‘ and ‘We Get Around’ point toward the darker, stranger corners Williams reached for under pressure. He has said ‘Pinesol’ drew on cold cases involving people who used household cleaners to cover their tracks, a macabre detail that suits a record remade in the shadow of scandal.
A Survival Story, Told in Real Time
Wavves has always been a project about surviving its own chaos. Williams built his reputation in the late 2000s on lo-fi noise-pop and a reputation for volatility, and his best work has often come from turning dysfunction into fuel. ‘Cherry Soda’ extends that pattern into territory he could not have scripted, an album that now functions as a document of what happens when an artist refuses to let someone else’s conduct sink his work.
The broader cultural moment gives the story weight. The music industry has spent years reckoning with how to respond when allegations surface against a collaborator, and the answers are rarely clean. Williams chose the most drastic option available, severing the connection and absorbing the cost himself rather than releasing a record with Bemis’s name on it. Whether that choice reads as principled or merely pragmatic, it is decisive in a way the industry has not always managed.
What remains is a Wavves album with an asterisk it did not ask for, released into a conversation about accountability that extends well beyond one scrapped partnership. ‘Cherry Soda’ will be judged on its songs, but it will be remembered for how it was saved. For an artist who has spent fifteen years making noise out of disorder, that may be the most Wavves outcome imaginable.

